Budgethotels in Fire Island

'Nice, cosy hotel, friendly service! Affordable (in comparison to the expensive neighbourhoud). Breakfast was very basic (no seating, only bagels), shared bathrooms and the bed was a bit uncomfortable.'

'Awesome as always. Love this place.'

'Best for quality, amenities and convenience.'

'The Penny Lane was an excellent place to stay if you are visiting Hampton Bays or surrounding area. Rooms are great. Bed was incredibly comfortable. Staff was excellent.'

'nice hotel, good beds, breakfast better then the other hotel chains!!!!'

'This is not a hotel. The room is clean, but it is extremely noisy. Room 1 is located directly above a billiard bar, making it very difficult to rest. There is no reception and no parking available. Overall, there is a lot of noise and the experience was disappointing.'

'Check-in was nice. Ashley at the front desk was very kind and helpful. The room was nice and clean. I would recommend this hotel to others.'

'The hotel and rooms are really nice. There is just no service. No one by the pool the bar is closed. They need more staff and then it would be great. Also, music by the pool would be nice. There was no vibe and a little boring. I went on the weekend and it should have full staff.'