Cottages in Shelter Island

'My sisters and I booked a 2 bedroom cottage for a long weekend around Greenport. The listing said it was a 2 bedroom with queen beds but when I arrived I realized one room was only a full so one of us had to sleep on the pull out couch for us all to be comfortable. You also definitely need a car. It’s a 45 min walk from the train station so if you’re coming from the city it’s not a convenient location and it’s off a busy road. The cottage did have lots of kitchen amenities and a grill which is...

'Wonderful house. Immaculate with all the provisions you can hope for. Perfect location and beautifully done!'

'Shalom cottage was perfect for my brief stay. It was very clean and comfortable with everything I needed. I wish I could have stayed longer!'

'Very nice cozy cottage, the host was very friendly'

'Camila was very communicative and helpful. The cottage clearly has a history of high traffic, and while it holds a certain rustic charm, it's undeniably showing its age. The property feels quite worn and tired, with fixtures and furnishings having seen better days. On the surface, the cottage was tidy upon arrival, but closer inspection revealed that it lacked a deep, thorough cleaning. While the main living areas were presentable, the corners, baseboards, and other area's not immediately...

'Cozy cottage was perfect for our long weekend in Madison!'