Cottages in Hillsgrove

'We had a phenomenal time! Thank you for providing such a great experience for us on Eaglesmere lake. The cabin was clean, well-stocked, and clearly well cared for, with thoughtful touches throughout. We left feeling totally refreshed and already planning our next trip back :)'

'It was very clean, maintained, and quite. The hosts were friendly and helpful '

'Wonderful, peaceful stay. Very clean and quiet. Thank you.'

'Great location in Lake Mokoma. I’ve stayed at 3 different properties over the past 3 yrs at LM & this is by far my favorite. Beach within walking distance and property accessible to running/walking trails throughout Lake Mokoma. Quiet in the evenings and all of the necessities were provided- towels/linens and coffee pods! Would definitely visit Katonah House again! Super enjoyed time spent reading in the evenings in the enclosed porch and happy hour on the front porch. Kayaks were available...

'My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the cottage. We were in town for the World’s End Ultra Marathon and were so grateful to have the cabin as our home base just 15 minutes from the trail. We’re looking forward to coming back again next year!'

'The view was beautiful, house was clean and plenty of room. '

'The property was clean and easy to find.We had a box fan we used at a previous VRBO in Sullivan County and this was helpful to have during the "heat wave" while we were vacationing.The sparkling water and bottle of wine were a nice welcome.'