Hotels in de buurt van Shell Beach (Shelter Island)

'Everything was better than advertised. We will definitely stay again.'

'Unique place but service too dependent on the individual server or concierge - some are incredible others are too slow and thereby under the level of this kind of accomodation '

'Bill is a wonderful and knowledgeable host for a beautiful getaway in a unique setting.'

'Stayed for two nights. At arrival I contacted the landlord as informed on the welcoming mail regarding a locked safe - still haven’t heard from them. Very cold bathroom floor, incredibly noisy AC and fridge. Not even a glass in either the room nor bathroom. Top it up properly a room on the second floor with very small steps and an almost 45 degree angel. Will not recommend to anyone and will never return…'

'Lovely lodging'

'The garden/lobby/playrooms/boardgames.. bruuuhhh can’t sleep? Just playing there boardgames w family or couple.. travel alone? They have bunch of magazines and books'

'A cozy room with great pillows and quiet. Perfect little place. '

'Beautiful property- we would definitely stay there again'

'Staff was very accommodating and extremely nice, Great stay!'

'Clean rooms. On the smaller side, so one full room barely comfortably seats 4 ppl. the pool was nice. the staff was very nice. comes with an outdoor seating area and a grill and a fire pit.'

'Close to everything in town. Breakfast was great! Rooms were very clean and well stocked.'

'Great location! Very clean! '

'Love being on the water'

'Amazing'

'Stylish, greets walkable location, loved the grounds and the snacks and wine '

'Recently enjoyed a few days at the Sagaponack before the "season"started. My accommodations were wonderful. The rooms are thoughtfully prepared with a few little extras that were such a nice touch. The staff was great and I appreciated the coffee bar stocked with morning essentials like yogurts, granola, breakfast bars and croissants or afternoon treats, like chips, fresh baked cookies and some sweet candies to grab and go. The setting was beautiful and the grounds impeccably maintained. I...