Herbergen in Plum Island

'The historian at the front was extremely friendly. What a gem of a man. The inn itself was GORGEOUS! Even though the rooms were small, it felt like you stepped back in time. This red headed hostess with glasses was very standoffish though. Did not greet guests with customer service at all. Also the food was a 6.5/10. The mud pie was amazing but they served green beans as a side vegetable. Just plain boiled, absolutely no seasonings or sauteeing. Overpriced entrees a tad. Cocktails were great...

'The backyard fire-pit area was a pleasant surprise. The food and drinks were great. We will return. '

'Make sure to stop for a drink at the Cellar beneath the inn!'

'The room was so clean and everything thing is organized very well. Bed was so comfortable. Thank you so much!'

'Was a very beautiful room. Wife loved the loved the tub in the room. Definitely going back one-day. '

'The staff were great. Loved the in-house tavern, pool, and patio!'

'Beautiful Inn. Very comfortable.'