The positives - spacious, plenty of options for dining indoor and outdoor, well maintained pool, good location in nice neighborhood, kayaks/bikes/pool accessories/floaties all available in garage
The negatives - The home is dated, as is the furniture (the couch could swallow you whole!). Outdoor furniture is rusty and there was some metal construction debris on the covered patio that could have caused real injuries. I know Ian cleanup is ongoing even this many months later, but we didn't imagine that it wouldn’t be safe to be barefoot on the covered patio poolside. We also struggled to find a broom so we could sweep up after meals. I dug one out of the garage but the dustpan was filthy and the broom was flimsy. They did offer a fresh, sealed sponge which we used to keep counters/table clean.
About the management company - they are cheap cheap cheap with offering general supplies. For an 8 day stay there were 2 dishwasher tabs provided, 4 rolls of 1-ply! toilet paper total - one in use and one backup per bathroom - for 10 guests, 1 roll of paper towel, no wrap/foil/baggies of any kind provided, and only 2 laundry tabs which I guess are allocated for the towels you are expected to wash upon checkout.
Our biggest issue - there are definitely NOT 5 bedrooms. This is a 3 bed home with a den and an open loft. One "bedroom" centrally located on the first floor has no closet And offers a pullout sofa that was so uncomfortable that we purchased an air mattress. The loft, which is also marketed as a bedroom, offers ZERO noise containment or privacy (aside from an ill-fitting curtain that makes no sense as it is way too short and only wide enough to cover about 25% of the exposed area up there). We stuck a kid up there because it made the most sense in our situation but that meant that we could not gather in the evening in the living space and with the pool screen gone, moving outdoor wasn't a great option either.
Final verdict - the place has potential but just isn't going to work for us for our annual trips to the area to visit family.