We liked the view of the lake. Also, the kitchen is well-laid out and has most utensils one might need. However, there were several misrepresentations in the listing, and several inhospitable policies, that collectively made us feel both a bit cheated and a bit unwelcome.
First, the listing said we could borrow kayaks and bikes from the house. Both my wife and I had noted that before booking, and we were looking forward to it. But after we committed to paying for a 10-day rental, that part of the listing apparently changed without notice to us, and there were neither bikes nor kayaks available for our use. Suggestion: if you want to change a material term of a contract after you've entered into it, first get the other party's agreement to the change.
Second, the listing said there is a fireplace. In fact, the fireplace was nonfunctional, and despite my asking about it twice, the owner refused to fix it. Suggestion: if your tenant is paying to rent your house, and you represented that there is a working fireplace, spend the money to fix it.
Additionally, far from making us feel like welcome guests in an upscale vacation home, a number of policies made us feel like cheap criminals or freeloaders. For example, the rules make it bizarrely clear that no coffee will be provided, and that after the allotment of toilet paper is used up, guests will have to buy their own TP. I've stayed in dozens of vacation rentals, and this is the only one that didn't provide coffee. Suggestion: if you had previous guests use up all of your coffee once or twice, then (1) you're still only out about $5, and (2) in any case, don't take it out on all future guests. Regarding the TP, we never ran out, but every time I used the toilet, it made me anxious to think we might. Motel 6 maids give out free TP to guests who ask. Is it really necessary to be that cheap?
Also, there was no facial tissue in the whole house, so we used TP to blow our noses when necessary. I would think a few boxes of facial tissue are also standard for a rental of this type.
As to the house itself, there appears to be no heat upstairs other than partial floor heat in the bathroom and a Franklin stove in the main bedroom. This means (1) it gets chilly in the bathroom, and (2) if you want to stay warm at night, count on the Franklin stove going off and on all night with the various noises that accompany that routine.
Overall, we would not rent this house again.