Cottages in Sag Harbor

'We had such a wonderful one night stay at Shalom Cottage! The place was absolutely beautiful—so cozy, clean, and thoughtfully decorated. Raj, the host was truly amazing! He was kind, responsive, and made sure we had everything we needed from start to finish. We felt so welcomed and comfortable the entire time. We would definitely love to stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone! '

'Great stay. Would stay again. '

'Pat was great, picked me up from the train station and brought me to the grocery store to grab some supplies. Place was cozy and super quiet/peaceful. I was here in January so I'd love to come back in the summer and enjoy the beach, which is right on the property.'

'I am a bit late to positing this review (stayed in November) but wanted to leave a recommendation for this cute spot for anyone who’s looking to stay here. It’s located in a cute neighborhood, close to beaches and nice walking areas. The house is a bit small, but we had a party of 6 people and 2 dogs, which ended up working well for us, as we were out of the house for most of the time we were there. The host was responsive and the checking in/ out process was clear and easy! Thank you! '

'Wonderful house. Immaculate with all the provisions you can hope for. Perfect location and beautifully done!'