Our middle son has a holiday home just over the Callicoon bridge in PA, and for a large family gathering we were seeking additional overnight accommodation for 10 nights.
The Catskills NY Barn House, provided the perfect solution for us as most of our time was spent at our son's home or out participating in activities, including eating out.
Our hosts, Sarah and Dustin, were especially friendly and helpful, and we did not want for anything during our stay. The welcome pack, cleaning service and linen change was much appreciated. If we were to visit the area again and require additional accommodation, we would certainly rebook.
If we had any criticisms it would be that the one toilet in the one shower room might be a bit of a challenge in the mornings if 5 persons were staying at the Barn, but the bedrooms and living room/kitchen area is big enough to accommodate them all.
Also, the Catskills NY Barn House stands beside and close to Sullivan County Route 121, which has a 45 mph speed limit. Young children require supervision and passing trucks can be quite noisy during the working day. But in the evenings and at weekends the route is quiet, with just the sound of the water passing over the rocks in the Callicoon Creek, on the opposite side of the road.
Finally, there are few effective curtains at the bedroom windows to keep out the light on long summer evenings and early mornings, so having an eye mask handy maybe appropriate.
All in all, a very enjoyable stay.